Who do you thinks is better Jacob Black or Edward Cullen?

Tell me the truth what character from twilight do you like better?
Who do you thinks is better Jacob Black or Edward Cullen?
I really hate how everyone keeps comparing these two characters. They are SO different, therefore it's not even fair to compare them. Edward is amazing, charming, dazzling, but is also incapable of getting upset! I mean, if my boyfriend was making out with another girl, I wouldn't comfort him and tell him it was okay. It really pissed me off that Edward wasn't angry with Bella when she made out with Jacob at the end of Eclipse. Okay, now for Jacob. Jake is caring, sweet, and LOYAL, but can be arrogant. The only reason Edward can hold Bella in his arms is because Jake saved her. I feel terrible how he loved Bella and got his heart ripped out. But Jake can be annoying and judgemental.





Anyway, sorry for the rant. I just hate how these two get compared. And I like them both the same. BUT Edward does belong with Bella.
Who do you thinks is better Jacob Black or Edward Cullen?
EDWARD EDWARD EDWARD EDWARD *droool*





Hmmm...I'll have to think about it, lol





Response:


I can respect that ^_^...besides, that means more Edward for me, and more Jacob for you. Everyone's happy!
Reply:Definitely Edward Cullen. He and Bella are way more meant-to-be than Jacob and Bella, and he has a way better personality. Vampires are just way cooler than werewolves in general, too. :-)
Reply:i like edward because i fell in love with him in twilight so i know how bella feels and i really really like jacob but just as a friend if i had to choose.
Reply:Edward and Jacob are both great Characters in the Twilight series, but I would have to say I like Edward better! Go Team Edward!!!
Reply:YAY!!!!!!! Someone agrees with me!!!!!


Yay!!! Another Team Jacob member!!!!!!!!








I am SO DEFINITELY TEAM JACOB all the way!





This is why: Jacob is such a loyal, caring, loving, great boy. He is such a good friend to Bella but all Bella did to him was use him again and again and break his heart.





Some prefer Jake because he is warm. Not like Edward.





Jacob is human, and there is SO MUCH he can give and do with Bella that Edward can't, because he will hurt her and kill her. With Edward, Bella has NO FUTURE. The only future she has with Edward is drinking blood and becoming a disgusting parasite. GROSS.





While with Jake, she can have a happy human life, She doesn't have to change or sacrifice anything just to be with Jacob. Jacob can give her so much, a family, children, and pure happiness. Jacob's love for Bella is more raw and pure. Wanna know why? Because he SURRENDERED for the girl he loves. He surrendered because he knows that Bella couldn't live without Edward and because Bella could only be happy with Edward. He surrendered to give the girl he loves to his immortal enemy. Despite everything he did for Bella, despite everthing Bella did to him, everything they've been through.....he SURRENDERED. Because he knows that his surrender is the key to Bella's happiness. He surrendered, knowing how much it would hurt him.





And he isn't perfect. He makes mistakes, has his own imperfection, making him all the more perfect for Bella.





It's so heartbreaking that Jacob always has to have the sad ending. A horrible ending in New Moon. A much more terrible one in Eclipse. When oh when will he finally find his happily ever after?





It is kinda annoying some people only hate him because of Edward's "hotness" and perfection. When I read the 3 books all I have to read about is how sweet his skin smells, how marble his chest is, how white his skin is, how cold his lips are, all physical! And, Bella also described Jake as a "very pretty face all in all" and "sort of beautiful" in the books, anyway. But Jacob isn't always described physically in the books. Bella knows him inside and out. Yes, Bella realized she's in love with him too, but she doesn't realize YET how truly and how really and how deeply she feels for him. She only realizes she's in love with him, but not how deepy, truly or really. I hope that's what she realizes in Breaking Dawn.





Don't get me wrong, Edward is sweet too, but slightly very overprotective. And it's kinda very controlling, manipulative and a bit abusive.





When Bella's with Jake, she is "free". She makes her own decisions, unlike when she's with Edward. Edward MAKES her make decisions which arent her own.





And do you like how light, weightless and easygoing Bella's personality is when she's with Jacob? Jacob can joke and she can have a laugh with him, but Edward just acts too maturely and too seriously about everything.





The main reason I'm on Jacob's team is because he is human. Period. He can make Bella happy, and he is the healthier choice for her. He isn't controlling, like Edward, and Bella has a happy human future with Jacob, family and children and love and all.....*sigh* If only Jacob and Bella could be together, if they did end up together, I'd be so happy I'd have tears of joy and I will be jealous of Bella....in a good way. I will be so happy for her. But if she chose Edward, I'd cry because of resentment and because it is the wrong choice for her. Humanity is very golden. We are all so lucky to have a life. But Bella--she chose Edward above all of this. *sigh* I think she made a wrong choice. I really hope she ends up with Jacob.





And it was mentioned that if the vampires never existed, then werewolves would never exist. If Edward Anthony Masen died in 1918 like he was supposed to, then there would be no more mystery and magic and creatures from horror movies in Bella's world. If the world was the sane place it was supposed to be, Jacob and Bella would be together. And they would've been happy. Jacob was the natural path Bella's life would have taken. They were really meant to be. That is what WOULD have been. And it's so sad. I could just cry right now.








I mean, think about it. About Bella. She has SO MUCH that she is going to give up, just for Edward?