Twilight or harry potter?

Which series do you prefer... Harry Potter or Twilight?? i prefer Harry Potter. and do you think Twilight will become the next Harry Potter? I say No. JK Rowling created a whole new world. There will be a next Twilight, but never in a long time, a next Harry Potter
Twilight or harry potter?
neither...sorry
Twilight or harry potter?
Harry Potter. I agree, Harry won't be replaced by Bella. It's kind of hard to create that kind of world.





Vampires have been used and even if you wanted to make them original you would still have to keep the skeleton of every vampire story. Wizards and Magic you can recreate in different ways though.
Reply:i'm with Twilight 100%
Reply:I love Twilight way more than Harry Potter. I read all of the books to both series and Twilight wins it for me. Hand down. Sorry. =)
Reply:i say harry potter is definatley better. it not only attracts all ages, but both genders. plus, the books are more detailed, and they dont just revolve around a few events, like twilight does.


hopefully it doesnt become the new harry potter [ doubt ]
Reply:I would say neither, because they seem to be in seperate genres.....
Reply:HP


T is not the next HP.
Reply:Harry Potter or Twilight . .


hmmmmmm


I'd say harry pot- . . .


Hah, yeah right!


Twilight all the way, baby!
Reply:Harry Potter. While it's hardly the most original work, JK Rowling created something that appeals to readers and touches their imaginations. Her characters are dynamic with various faults, strengths, and personal problems. While the novel takes place in an unfamiliar world of magic, there is something in every situation the reader can relate to. There is still a sense of realism that connects the reader to the story. Although I doubt Harry Potter will ever become a classic, Rowling's novel will survive throughout several generations because of its appeal to various age groups and the exciting tale it weaves.





Twilight, on the other hand, is more of a fad novel than one to be enjoyed for years to come. It is geared toward one group of people: teenage/middle school girls. This group is often changing from one extreme to the other from year to year. The book will fade out in a few years because of this. Meyer's characters tend to be two dimensional, dull, and just unrealistic. They are difficult, if not impossible, to relate to. It's all about love at first sight and romantic teenage fluff. As time passes, more fad books like Twilight will be created, forcing Twilight to fade into oblivion.





No, I don't belive Twilight will be the next Harry Potter. Like you said, JK Rowling created a whole new world full of interesting characters and exciting events. There's really nothing new about Twilight. It's cliche...it's been done before. It is going to be a long time before something as unique and wide sweeping as Harry Potter is created. The next Twilight will be created within the next year or so.
Reply:Twilight, defianantly.


I mean Harry Potter is pretty great but it's for younger readers, and not as deep and gripping as twilight. Edward is so just sooo...... one of a kind-never gonna find a guy like him person. I'm doomed, i compare everyone to him, so im probably never gonna fall in love again. :)


Only the best book in the world can do that to a girl.
Reply:Harry Potter!!!! 100%





Nope, I don't think Twilight will be the next Harry Potter...
Reply:TWILIGHT.
Reply:i like them both but 4 different reasons. i mean, Twilight wen i want, well, Edward. and harry potter when i want adventure and mystery and fun characters. i mean, Twilight is easier to read and, once again, has Edward, but Harry has been in my heart longer (disclaimer: i never fell in a swoon-ful love for harry or any of the characters. i just liked them. The cullens however...)


however, i disagree with ur statement of "there will be a next Twiilight..." because that book series is growing like crazy! as 4 hp, its over. i mean, it was fabulous, but its done. and everyone who would read it, probably has. Twilight, however, is still recommendable because there are still millions of people who havent even heard of it. But everyone knows about harry potter. and thats just one of those books where either you read it, or you choose not to and move on. Harry potter is slowly fading away. it's sad but true. Twilight, however, is getting stronger each sale. i mean, if you want to think of it that way.


But i love them, well, not equally, but differently. (and i think Neville is awesome)


;-)
Reply:Most definitely Harry Potter series. J.K Rowling created a fantastic book series that is just in a class of its own. It's probably one the best fantasy novels ever written, and that's saying something when you consider that there are classics like The Lord of the Rings by Tolkien and The Chronicles of Narnia by Lewis. I think that the Twilight series is great, but it's no where near as popular and interesting as Harry Potter, and it will never be better.





HP rocks!!!





:)